Posts Tagged ‘Economic Forecast’
Phily Fed Survey: More of the Same
The quarterly survey of forecasters, produced by the Philadelphia FED, is one of my regular touchstones for where the economy is headed. One caveat — in “steady” times, they tend to be pretty accurate. They miss black swan events, but so do everyone.
That said, they are look at annualized GDP growth of about 3% in the coming quarter and about 2.6% in the following quarter. Job growth will decline into 2019, adding about 195,000 jobs per month this year, declining to about 165,000 next year. However, unemployment will remain pretty much where it is. Inflation continues to be a non-event. These numbers pretty much make sense, if you consider there is a pretty strong tail wind. We’ve been on a positive trend since about 2010, and in the absense of systemic shocks to the system, why worry?
I’ve noted in the past that this group of forecasters tend to be fairly… ahhh, I hate to use the word lazy, but what the heck. They mostly work for banks and such, and so have a bit of a bias in favor of good times ahead. That’s one of the reasons they tend to miss negative signals. I’ve noted here in past posts that the yield curve is approaching a dangerous inverted shape (for the uninitiated, this isn’t just reading tea leaves — it tells us a lot about the expectations of borrowers and lenders). The trade war only gets worse, and we’re seeing increasing disruptions in agriculture and manufacturing here in the U.S. as a result. I’m not trying to be Chicken Little, but this is certainly influencing my thinking.
Share this:
December’s Livingston Survey
The late columnist Joseph A Livingston started surveying economists about their forecasts back in 1946. It’s the oldest continuing survey of its kind, and is continued twice a year under the auspices of the Philadelphia Federal Reserve Bank. One of the neat things about this semi-annual report is that it compares the current central tendency of projections to the projections which were being made six months ago. In short, we can directly compare how economic forecasts are changing over time.
One of the biggest shifts is in the GDP growth rate for the 2nd half of 2015. Six months ago, economists were projecting that we’d end the year with a modestly healthy 3.1% annual rate of growth. Now, economists are forecasting we’ll end the year at about 2.1% — a fairly significant shift in sentiment. Similar declines in GDP growth are projected for 2016. Check my prior blog post about the 12th District report on the western economy, and particularly the impact a stronger dollar is having on the export market.
The good news — and it’s slight — is an improvement in the projections about unemployment. Six months ago, economists were forecasting we’d end the year with an unemployment rate of 5.1%. This has now been revised downward, ever so slightly, to 4.9%. Also, inflation continues to be dead-on-arrival. From the end of 2014 to the end of 2015, the consumer price index is projected to rise only 0.1%, in line with prior forecasts, and the producer price index is actually projected to fall by 3.2%. Both indices are expected to swell in the coming year, but only slightly. The current CPI forecast for the coming year is 1.8%, and PPI is 0.7%. I’ll leave it up to the reader to pick a reason for this, but can you say “energy costs”?
Six months ago, interest rates were forecasted to rise. Actual increases are somewhat lower than previously forecasted. Six months ago, forecasters predicted we’d end the year with 3-month T-bill rates at 0.59%. In reality, the November 23 auction was at 0.14%, although rates are trending up in December (0.28% as of Monday) in anticipation of Fed rate increases. The current forecast is for 3-month rates to end the year around 0.23%, and for 1-year rates to end around 2.3% (down from the previously forecasted 2.5%). Forecasters currently predict 3-month T-bills will hit 1.12% by the end of 2016, and 10-year notes will end next year around 2.75%.
Finally, forecasters are asked to predict the S&P 500 index for the end of the year as well as the end of next year. Six months ago, the consensus forecast was an S&P level of 2158 for the end of the year, and this has now softened to 2090. (It’s helpful to note that the S&P opened just under 2048 this morning.) Forecasters currently project the S&P will hit about 2185 by the end of next year, which is an anemic growth of 4.5% over the coming 12 months.
If you’d like your own copy, which includes much more detail on these forecasts, you can download it for free here.
Share this:
Quarterly Econ Survey from Phily FED
One of my favorite regular “reads” is the Survey of Professional Forecasters” from the Philadelphia Federal Reserve Bank. The main survey comes out quarterly, with occasional special editions thrown in along the way. The brilliance of the survey is its simplicity — ask a large panel of economic forecasters where they think the economy is going in terms of a handful of key indicators — GDP, unemployment, inflation. Then calculate the median and the range of responses.
The medians are fairly predictable and “sticky” (that is, this quarter’s results look a lot like last quarter’s). However, the interesting stuff is buried in the way the distribution of results change. For example, both the last survey and the current survey find that the largest number of economists think unemployment will average between 7.0% and 7.4% next year (with a median of 7.1%), down somewhat from this year. That’s pretty predictable stuff. However, this year’s distribution is skewed to the low side (a very large number of economists think unemployment will dip this year and end up as low as 7% on average) but next year, the distribution is fairly even, with the bulk of economists forecasting anywhere from 6% to 8%. In short, 2014 is pretty cloudy right now, and that means that hedging your economic bets isn’t a bad idea.
GDP projections are somewhat less rosy. In the previous survey (2nd quarter, 2013), the largest number of economists projected 2013 GDP in the 2% to 3% range, with the median at 2%. Today, that has dropped a full half-percentage point, down to 1.5%. Previously, 2014 was projected at 2.8%, and that has now been downgraded to 2.6%, although as we’ve already established, 2014 is pretty much a guessing game.
Inflation continues to be pretty-much a flat line, with a lot of “1.8%” and “2.0%” on the chart. In short, hardly anyone sees inflation above 2.3% or so in the foreseeable future.
To download the full report, go to http://www.philadelphiafed.org/research-and-data/real-time-center/survey-of-professional-forecasters/2013/survq313.cfm
From a small northwestern observatory... 